A Wounded Heart

One week ago today, I was sitting in the John Glenn International Airport in Columbus, OH waiting to board a flight to Chicago where I would catch a connecting flight to Newark, NJ. It was my birthday. I’d already spent the day up until that point working, and I knew that I would be spending the rest of the day in the air or in airports, getting into Newark just before midnight, but I knew that I was flying to join friends, comrades and colleagues in the struggle for full inclusion within the United Methodist Church. Full inclusion, such a nice sterile way of saying that I wish my church would stop wounding those who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, questioning, non-binary, and anyone else who doesn’t fit within the crosshairs of cisgender hetero-normativity that the church holds as the only acceptable way of being in the world, as if they have the right to look at Creation and say that what the Creator has made is not good.

A few days after my arrival, the United Methodist Church’s equivalent of the Supreme Court, the Judicial Council, would be ruling on the constitutionality (according to church law, not real law) of the election, consecration, and appointment of Bishop Karen Oliveto as well as the rights of the Boards of Ordained Ministry in Upstate New York and Northern Illinois to choose to not include sexual orientation as criteria for a person’s a relevant criteria for candidates for ordination. Right now, the United Methodist Book of Discipline doesn’t contain any language directly aimed at persons who are transgender or gender non-conforming. I’m sure that the denomination, which laughably boasts as its motto, “open hearts, open doors, open minds,” will remedy that oversight at some point.

I’m really trying to pull my thoughts together in some way that is hopeful, or even helpful. It is a struggle at this point.

I was flying into New Jersey a few days ahead of the public portion of the Judicial Council meeting, which was held on Tuesday, April 25^th.  On Sunday and Monday, I would be in meetings with other members of the Affirmation Council. Affirmation is the oldest LGBTQ+ supportive organization in the United Methodist world. They are the organization that created the Reconciling Ministries Network, and they maintain a sibling relationship with other progressive organizations that have organized together under the umbrella of the Love Your Neighbor Coalition. I connected with their current understanding of their mission, which is essentially that of chaplaincy for those who have been hurt or wounded by the actions and discriminatory policies of the United Methodist denomination. It was great being able to spend two full days with this small group of people, engaged in discussions about how we can best devote our time and resources to caring for those who are hurting.

Very early on Tuesday morning, I arose, got ready, and packed my luggage as I would be heading to the airport to return home as soon as the public oral arguments were concluded. When we arrived at the Hilton near Newark Penn Station to get in line for tickets in hopes of being able to be in the room where Judicial Council was meeting, I saw many faces that I recognized from the past two General Conferences and from Reconciling Ministries Network convocation events. I was among friends, which was comforting, but I couldn’t help but wonder. Where were those who thought differently? It is clear that there are those who oppose full inclusion. Otherwise, this fight would have been over a long time ago. Didn’t they care enough to show up to show support for their beliefs? Apparently, that was not a priority for them. It makes sense that many of them were probably preparing for ‘We Believe in the Church,’ a conference held by the Wesleyan Covenant Association, a group of conservative, evangelical United Methodists who have banded together to resist any efforts aimed at the inclusion of LGBTQ+ persons in the denomination. Of course, as their new president and counsel for the South Central Jurisdiction in their complaint against Bishop Oliveto Keith Boyette will tell you, they support LGBTQ persons being included in “all aspects of the church.” I about fell over when he said this in the hearing room as his definition of “all aspects” clearly does not include marriage, the pulpit, or the episcopacy.

As I am currently in my final semester of grad school, I am currently working a part-time retail job in order to put some cash in my pocket as I finish up an internship. I was at that job last night. I had read from multiple sources throughout the day that the Judicial Council probably would not deliver its ruling until Saturday, today. As I took my 15-minute break last night, I pulled out my cell phone. As soon as I began scrolling through my newsfeed on Facebook, I felt as if the wind had been knocked out of me. The ruling from the court had been announced. The election of Bishop Oliveto was declared to be illegal, and people across the denomination were hurting. I read as much as I could before returning to work, but a feeling of numb emptiness would be with me the rest of the evening. I forced on a plastic smile and resumed interacting with customers, masking the hurt that I was feeling on the inside. At the end of my shift, I sat in front of a computer in the store’s storage room and clocked out. I sat there for a few minutes more, scrolling through more and more expressions of hurt from so many people. I finally managed to get up and walk to my car where I, again, sat reading even more before I finally put the phone down and started the engine.

With Bishop Oliveto in Newark, NJ

Today, I am still feeling the hurt and wounding. As someone who has experienced deep hurt at the hands of religious institutions, this is not going to be an easy one for me to get over. I keep reminding myself that I attend a progressive church in a progressive city with many other progressive churches. For me, my life will not change much. I do feel called to ministry, but my calling does not require ordination as my calling can be walked out with a state licensure in a counseling office. I won’t lie. It has crossed my mind that maybe this is where I cross my red line. Maybe this is where I call it quits with the church. That thought is met by a sarcastic rebuttal from within myself though, a voice that says, “Oh. What a privilege it must be to be you?  Go ahead. Protect yourself. Just walk away while others are hurting.”

I am not leaving the church…yet. I have no immediate plans to do so either. Part of me is excited to possibly be witness to the formation of something new, a new inclusive denomination or other progressive religious structure, some new wine skins for our new wine. I am also hopeful for the work of the Commission on the Way Forward. I am also encouraged by the fact that, as of today, Karen Oliveto is still a bishop in the United Methodist Church, and, regardless of where events take us from here, she will always bear the honorific in my heart.

If you actually made it to the end of this, thank you for listening to the outpourings of my wounded heart.

~ Culbs

A Few Thoughts on Palm Sunday Morning

Sometimes I sit down with the conscious idea of writing a blog post. That was not the intent this morning when I sat down to begin working through some thoughts of what Palm Sunday means in general and what it means to me specifically. So, I apologize if this doesn’t seem as coherent as it might have been had I planned it out. This is one of those times that I just started typing a few thoughts for my own benefit, and my fingers just kept going.

As I reflect on what that first actual Palm Sunday must have felt like all those years ago in Jerusalem and knowing how the events of the following week would unfold, I try to place myself in the context of one of those in the crowd, welcoming him into the city placing my cloak or a branch upon the ground to prepare a path for him. As I think on this, trying to conjure up within me the emotions that must have been felt, imagining a crowd filled with an overwhelming sense of joy, celebration, and certain victory that must have been felt in anticipation of this King, this Savior, I cannot help but draw parallels to our modern political context.

I find myself back in the early evening hours of November 8, 2016, as I gathered with a group of progressive friends at Union Café in the Short North in Columbus, OH. I share the location as part of the context because it emphasizes the progressive bubble that I had placed myself in that evening. As we ordered food and drinks, the atmosphere was celebratory. We didn’t know exactly what the outcome of the vote would be in each state, but we did feel confident that we were about to witness history as the first woman was about to be elected as President of the United States of America.

As with most things, events in 2017 unfold much faster than they did in ancient Jerusalem. As we sat together at that table, we experienced all of the layers of Holy Week within just a few hours rather than days. We very quickly moved from welcoming a savior to seeing the unfolding of a long building crucifixion, and, before I went to bed that night, the darkness and hopelessness of Black Friday had descended with no apparent hope of a resurrection.

This was my second time experiencing this feeling of hopelessness as I had felt it 8 years prior when John McCain failed to win in the general election over then Senator Barack Obama. Again, insulated with a political bubble of conservative friends and campaign volunteers in the campaign headquarters of the Republican Party in Muskingum County in Zanesville, Ohio. Of course, at that time, my political beliefs were very different. I was still in a state of denying the truth of my identity as a gay man, and the denial of my own marginalization blinded me to how others were even more marginalized than I was. On that night, the night of Tuesday, November 4, 2008, I felt that fully eclipsing darkness and absence of hope for the first time. In the interest of full honesty, I believe that it was these feelings of hopelessness that had been the culmination of weeks and months of phone banking and advocating for “my candidate” in 2008 that kept me from fully engaging in the campaign of Secretary Clinton in 2016. On some level, I know that I fearing that, if I invested so much of myself only to lose again, I could not bear it.

So, when I realized that I had, yet again, found myself in the same place for a second time, I began to wrestle with two questions. The first was, “What did I learn from the last time I was in that place that can help me now?” And the second was, “What have I learned from both of these experiences that can carry me forward into the future?” The first obvious lesson to me was that not engaging in the process had not protected me from getting hurt. The second lesson is one that many of us have wrestled with in the months since the election. It is the recognition that we need to find ways to connect with others who are outside our insular bubbles. These few months have also made me become even more aware of my privilege in culture and society. Despite being gay, I get to inhabit the world every day as a white able-bodied cisgender man. When Donald Trump became President of the United States, I began to once again, as I had felt for decades in my small hometown, to feel the ever-present pressure that stems from the one aspect of me that makes me other, that makes me marginalized. When I became aware of this within me, I had to check myself and remind that inner me that I am far more secure than so many others in the U.S. and the world. I don’t wake each morning with the fear of deportation or of military attacks or bombings outside my home. I struggle at times in terms of my finances, as many do, but I have never gone hungry, without shelter, or without medical care.

The final, and most important lesson in terms of relevance to Palm Sunday that I take from these events is that resurrections do happen, even if they take time. It would take over a year for me to move from seeing Barack Obama as a figure to be feared to being a figure to be revered. I doubt that I will ever make that inner journey in terms of my beliefs with Donald Trump, but I also believe that this experience has shown me that resurrection seldom happens in the ways that we expect. I am seeing signs of resurrection even within my own state of Ohio right now as people of all political beliefs are becoming more politically engaged and aware. I am also seeing non-discrimination protections for LGBTQ+ persons pass in small towns and cities within Ohio with far less debate and controversy. I have journeyed a great deal in the eight years that passed between my Black Friday moments. I pray that I will never have to endure another, but I know that it is likely that I will. So, as the followers of Christ saw the need to maintain hope in the world through sharing their stories of a Risen Savior, I ,too, put my hands back to the plough and commit to doing my part to bringing about a resurrection world.

~Culbs